In this day and age
what defines a man? Is it certain characteristics or traits, a
persons pride or ability to claim that he is a man? A very sensitive
topic, but an important one never the less. But an even more
important question is, how does a man claim his pride and cling on to
his man hood, as a slave, during the time of slavery? Constantly
being tested to break your spirit. How do you feel that you are a
man, when you keep being told that you don't even qualify to be a
human? Trying to define yourself as a man when you have things that
constantly defy the laws of your manhood is a difficult experience
like no other. Toni Morrison makes us aware of this ;situations,
through the experiences of Paul D, last of the Sweet Home men, in
Beloved. Paul D is an amazing character in Beloved, because he has
gone through hell trying to reclaim the very essence of his manhood
and open that “ Rusted tobacco tin” heart. By having the ability
to be patient, understanding, and being able to face his fears, Paul
D was able to hold on to his manhood and love himself, because if you
don't love yourself, your not allowing others to love you.
Paul D lived at
Sweet Home, which was ironically not so sweet at all, but it was the
only home he knew. He lived under the control of Mr and Mrs Garner.
Under M.r Garner Paul D thought he was man only because Mr Garner
claimed all his Sweet Home slaves were “men, not niggers.” He
claimed his manhood at Sweet Home. After the pass of Mr. Garner, the
slave master widow could not take care of all the slaves by herself
so she brought in Schoolteacher, an extremely racist and brutal slave
master, to help control the slaves. Life as a slave was already like
hell, Schoolteacher ignited the flames even more. He tortured the
slaves at Sweet Home, Sixo, Halle, Sethe, Paul D, Paul A, and Paul F,
with extreme oppression and strict rules. He broke their spirit,
crushed their souls, and pushed the slaves to the point where they
had to escape or die trying. Halle was tortured and had his spirit
broken when Schoolteacher had his wife Sethe raped right in front of
his eyes and her milk taken from her breasts, his children's milk.
Halle couldn't bear to watch and went insane, smearing butter all
over his face. “There is always my husband squatting by the churn
smearing butter as well as its clabber all over his face because the
milk they took is on his mind.”(83). The butter symbolized the
thought of his children's milk that was taken from Sethe. Paul D
watched Halle have his manhood pushed to most extreme level of
watching his wife being raped and not being able to stop it, Halle
was definitely broken after that. Paul D felt broken as well because
he was not able to help him or even say anything to Halle because of
the iron bit that was placed in his mouth. “ I had a bit in my
mouth, (82)” says Paul D as he explains to Sethe why he couldn't
speak to Halle. Paul D 's memories of Sweethome puts him in pain.
Paul D buries his
feelings and lives his life by never getting too attached to
anything. The life of a lonely Wonderer. After Mr. Garners leave Paul
D questioned his manhood and what makes him a man. Was it just
because Mr. Garner said he was at Sweet home? Paul D was very
insecure about his masculinity. He compared himself with Halle and
Sixo, like what made them men without question. He looked at both of
them as men. He Sixo as a great man because he would walk miles and
miles just to see his woman only for a brief second. Sixo died trying
to escape the plantation. Paul D couldn't even full fill his sexual
desires with a woman as they did. The only sexual encounter he had at
Sweet home was with the cows on the plantation. But it was deeper
than just because Halle and Sixo had women of their own or a family.
Watching Halle being torn apart from the ones he loved physically and
emotionally, made Paul D not want get attached to anything.
After Sweet home
Paul D questions his manhood even more, without Mr. Garner there to
claim he is a man. He becomes part of a chain gain for attempting to
kill his new slave master, Brandywine. He endures so much trauma
while being part of the chain gain that he is barely able to speak of
it for the memories haunt him. Paul D is emotionally unavailable.
While traveling and being part of the chain gain, Paul D sleeps in
ditches and is even forced to perform oral sex on a white man. His
memories of the past are painful and he doesn't like to relive them.
It was impossible for him to think he was a man when he wasn't even
treated as a human.
Its only when Paul
D arrives at 124 and finds Sethe do things become a little more clear
for him. Sethe welcomes him in, surprised by his arrival. The two
catch up and Sethe informs him of Baby Suggs death, Halle's mother.
Paul D feels welcomed in the house but is worried about the baby
ghost Beloved. He starts to stay with Sethe, Denver and Beloved at
124, like a family man. He even finds a job and getts Denver, Sethes
daughter, to open up when he takes them to the carnival. He feels
some sort of family orientation at 124. Its not only when him and
Sethe start conversing about the past does Paul D start questioning
wether he should stay at 124 or not, but Beloved also helps move him
out. “But she moved him nonetheless, and Paul D didn't even know
how to stop it because it looked like he was moving himself.(114)”
Seeing Beloved made Paul D question his manhood once more.
Paul D couldn't
allow for Sethe to love him properly, because he couldn't open up
that “tobacco tin” heart of his. Paul D left Sethe and 124, but
he realized something before he did. He realized Sethe's past.
Beloved seduced Paul D and at that moment it was like as if he had
made love to Sethe's past, because Beloved was her past haunting her.
It opened up his “tobacco tin” heart of his. It made him realize
he wasn't the only one with a dark past and that no one gets over it
alone. But, he did not realize this only till after he left 124. He
came tor up 124 and left. Although that was thought of as a
characteristic trait that black men had at that time as Baby Suggs
said, “men will be men, they come into your life tare everything up
and then leave,(26)” it wasn't something that defined Paul D's
manhood.
During Paul D's
absence from 124, he realized that he had to face his fears of
allowing someone to love him. He became understanding of Sethes and
her past because he realized he isn't alone and couldn't his past and
fears alone. He became understanding of Sethe's choices and returned
to 124. Beloved which helped drive him out was no longer there, but
that wasn't the only reason for his return. He knew to claim his
manhood he could not leave the house of 124 in the shape he left it
in. “ Afterward-not before-he considered Sethe's feelings in the
matter. And it was the lateness of his consideration that made him
feel so bad. (200)” It took Paul D a while to come to understanding
Sethe's feelings but, once he did he knew now that a man finished
what he started and he couldn't walk out on them having aroused all
these emotions and memories. It took him time to realize what he must
do as a man, but he was patient and understanding of that and Sethe's
past. He had to come back to 124 and face his fears of loving and
being loved.